We can finally announce our winner for the “Let it Snow Competition”. As usual, your thoughts and discussion are very welcome at the bottom of the page!
Congratulations to Maria Batista and Alexander Hohman, who sent us the concept which our panel chose as the winner.
Here is what Maria and Alexander have to say about it…
As architectural acupuncture within the built environment the design emphasized the re-appropriation of space, specifically the re-design of the well-worn assumptions concerning the function of a component within a network of infrastructure— the light post. We calculated that by replacing five light posts in every square mile we could provide enough housing on the streets for the houseless population of Edinburgh. Intended as a statement against social inequity, we resisted the temptation to simply supply housing, instead wishing to render houselessness visible. We hoped that in seeing the condition of poverty it would generate social change rendering the design unnecessary.
The things that particularly impressed our judges were the integration and use of existing city infrastructure, the close consideration of how the units can be implemented in the city, and the daring approach. It’s true that the homeless using these units are made almost into a spectacle- beacons within the city- which is an uncomfortable thing for the city at large to live with. It is perhaps not the most achievable or economical concept we received, but it is one of a handful of entries which really stands out by making a social comment on the plight of homelessness- challenging us that it’s not a problem we should shy away from by providing a neat answer but instead a problem that we should face and feel uneasy with.
We couldn’t let these five designs pass by unappreciated, as our judges all felt that they explored very interesting aspects of the brief…
Corina S. Dumitrescu http://cocoknotsdesigns.blogspot.com/
After a few days of looking around/researching, I have decided there is no better way of helping the homeless than through awareness:
Solutions such as jackets, tents or shelters are temporary bandages that cannot mend a deep wound in our society. The energy invested in these fast-fixes, most times turn out to be a waste of resources. That is why I am proposing a strategic use of funds to expose our neglected communities for what they really are, drawing continuous attention and funds toward the betterment of our society.
Enjoy Reality TV? Your typical winter jacket receives a webcam, streaming real-time from your local homeless community. These cameras would imply extra security, and would transform the life and stories of the homeless into reality TV. This powerful media trend would in turn attract viewers from all over the world, raising a continuous flow of awareness and funds, the main two ingredients in the abolition of homelessness.
Adam Park, a student at University of Sheffield School of Architecture.
The key idea behind the ’emergency winter shelter’ is to adapt existing urban infrastructure that might be otherwise un(der)used during the night hours. Relatively practicable modifications using existing campervan technology could transform a bus stop into a temporary, insulated & secure place to spend the night.
Peter O’Brien from Perth, Australia
Combining the traditional park bench with short-term homeless emergency shelter, the Bench»Pod offers refuge to those in urgent need. Town Planners typically design park benches with an aim to discourage the homeless from “dossing”. The Bench»Pod challenges this approach. When open, the Bench acts as a traditional park bench; but when required, the shell rotates down neatly to create a warm, dry and safe cocoon that helps protect its occupant from the cold, unsympathetic elements.
The Pod provides security for person and possessions, a degree of privacy and modesty, and a better night’s sleep to those in desperate need. Comprising a steel frame with an 8’ long PVC bench/bed and shell, the Bench»Pod is a durable, low maintenance, affordable and humanitarian design. The Bench»Pod is not intended to be the ultimate solution; its humble yet humanitarian purpose is to help soften the pain of homelessness and to help restore dignity to those affected.
Laurence Chan from Australia & Ryoyu Kido from Japan
We believe the homeless are not powerless, they just need a place to express themselves and be free.. The meaning of abandoned structures are not lost upon us, for we see them as the homeless of our urban fabric. Instead of offering a ‘solution’ to a ‘problem’, our proposal is an agent of change, where the abandoned people inhabit and colonize abandoned spaces. The spaces are re-appreciated and modified to the user’s needs, the users empower themselves through expressing and accepting their own identity. The colony however, is only part of the ‘solution’ to a wider problem of neglect and abandonment the homeless faces daily, and it would take more than such an initiative to ensure the well-being of the homeless.
Most of our assumption about the homeless are speculative, based chiefly through various media reports and personal experiences. However, the Homeless World Cup held annually serve as our main inspiration in how far the homeless can go when given a chance to shine, and the Urban Nomad Colony encapsulates the various activities that can give them this chance.
Concept_ To create a self-sustaining network of embedded shelters within the urban fabric of a city by marrying practices of consumer advertising and with the principles of social welfare. In this sense, a symbiotic relationship is formed between opposite ends of the economic spectrum.
Advertise_ Building on the opportunistic nature of the concept, the [re]shape design serves a dual purpose. In their compact (daytime) configuration they act as a new form of urban advertising, generating funding for their construction and continued maintenance. In the evening they unfold into a new form of urban infrastructure, providing shelter to those in need while serving to increase the visibility of the advertisement.
Transform_ Millions of pounds of PVC from billboard advertisements are dumped into landfills every year due to an inability to dispose of the material in an environmentally responsible manner. While the virtual indestructibility of PVC may pose environmental concerns, it is extremely advantageous for those seeking temporary shelter. Recognizing the opportunity to solve two problems with one solution, the [re]shape module re-uses billboards as its primary material for the shelter enclosure.
Shelter_ Much like the growth of the chambered nautilus, the [re]shape module progressively unfolds into differentiated chambers, accommodating a single occupant or multiple people as needed. The vinyl and tensile structure of the chambers nest into each other during the day, compacting into anything from an unassuming billboard to a city bus stop.
And a little mention on the end…
We’d like to give a shout out to a group to students from Monterrey, Mexico, who unfortunately didn’t manage to meet the competition deadline but decided to send their entries anyway for us to have a look at. Thanks very much, we enjoyed discussing your work!